« Six Tools to Keep China From Making Trouble | Main | The Iraq War is an Arab Opportunity, but Lasting Democracy Needs a Lasting US Commitment »

May 03, 2005

The Paramilitary Dilemma: Should We Recruit Iraqi Thugs to Beat Iraqi Thugs?

Praktike spots a trend in Iraq: whether it's paramilitary commandos employed by the government, or paramilitary militias that "pop up" on their own, the war against the Iraqi insurgents is increasingly being fought by Iraqi paramilitaries. This is good news and bad news. Paramilitaries are Iraq's best hope for quick peace -- and also a force that could spark mass killings or civil war.

Most counterinsurgency successes since World War Two, especially the few quick counterinsurgency successes, have relied on paramilitaries. Paramilitaries have unique advantages against insurgents that regular police and soldiers don't -- they combine the strengths police and soldiers each have against insurgents, and leave behind the weaknesses that insurgents try to exploit. These militias and commandos may be Iraqis' only hope to get peace on the streets in months instead of years.

But paramilitaries in Iraq are also bad news: unless the government handles them very carefully, anti-insurgent militias and commandos tend to become as brutal as the insurgents. And because the paramilitaries have the backing of the government, they have the potential to take over the country and kill their personal and political enemies in numbers the insurgents can only dream of. It's happened before.

The paramilitary solution to insurgency

Successful counterinsurgencies usually involve a network of paramilitary "local self-defense" militias, or else an entire national paramilitary professional organization. Historical examples include the Italian carabinieri, which led the effort against the Communist Red Brigades; Peru's endorsement of local militias called rondas campesinas, which turned around the fighting against the Shining Path guerrillas; or the village commando units set up to fight the Hukbalahap insurrection in the Philippines. Probably the best-documented example of paramilitaries' edge against insurgents is, ironically, the Vietnam War.

During the Vietnam War, there were only three programs that actually succeeded in shutting down communist guerrilla activity in their areas. Those were the CIA-administered (using Special Forces personnel) Civilian Irregular Defense Groups (CIDG), the Marines' Combined Action Platoons (CAP), and late in the war the joint Army-civilian Civil Operations and Revolutionary (later Rural) Development and Support (CORDS) program. All three programs ignored the hundreds of thousands of regular American and Vietnamese troops on battalion-sized maneuvers. CIDG, CAP and CORDS all focused on building up and supporting tiny local village militias. And CIDG, CAP and CORDS all succeeded in shutting down guerrilla activities in their areas of operation.

Insurgents defeat police by being more focused and more violent. Insurgents beat soldiers by building ties with the civilians. They lose those advantages against paramilitaries. Whether we're talking about informal militias or formal commando units, paramilitaries, like police detectives, make their habit to operate among local civilians and persuade them to become helpers and informants. But like soldiers, paramilitaries don't spend their days walking a beat to prevent public disorder; they use their informants to point out the government's enemies so they can capture or kill them.

Insurgents intimidate or persuade people to help them kill government supporters. Paramilitaries intimidate or persuade people to help them kill insurgents. Since the paramilitaries are on the same side as the government, they can talk to more people safely, offer bigger bribes, and move around faster and in larger groups than the insurgents. Insurgents rely on staying "asymmetric" to make up for lack of resources. Paramilitaries are a "symmetric" counter to insurgents, using their own tactics against them with the advantages of government support.

The most recent example of paramilitary success against insurgents is Afghanistan today. While it's easy to find things to complain about in Afghanistan, the Taliban there haven't been able to muster anything like the kind of continual attacks that the Iraqi insurgents have. In Afghanistan, we endorsed the local gunmen instead of bringing in our own. The result was that whenever the Taliban tried to reinfiltrate a village or city, there were plenty of local fighters in a position to find out about them and run them back out of town. The warlords' militias kept Afghanistan secure from the Taliban. Of course, now the warlords' militias are a problem of their own -- and that's part of the dark side of paramilitaries.

When paramilitaries go bad

Because paramilitaries have a license to find and kill the enemies of the government, they have almost absolute power in their local community -- and absolute power corrupts absolutely. It's only too easy for paramilitaries to create excuses to kill off anyone in town who crosses them. From Peru to Vietnam, militias have tended to conveniently discover that their personal enemies were enemies of the state. Worse, paramilitaries can use an insurgency to seize power for themselves and set up their own psuedo-governmental empire. That's what's happened in much of Columbia, where the right-wing paramilitaries long ago became more involved in being the government and in running drugs than in helping the government against rebels. But even replacing the government isn't the worst thing that unbound paramilitaries will do.

Paramilitaries only tend to be needed in weakly governed countries, and weakly governed countries tend to have nasty ethnic or class feuds just below the surface -- especially once an insurgency breaks out. If the government lets the paramilitaries take too much authority, the result tends to be ethnic cleansing -- or genocide. In El Salvador, despite American advisors' complaints the counter-guerrilla forces killed 70,000 supposedly left-wing people out of the country's six million. In Guatemala, where America withdrew in disgust, the paramilitary army slaughtered 200,000, mostly ethnic Maya and almost all civilians, out of a population of only 10 million. In Rwanda, in Bosnia, and in Sudan today, the key step for ethnic slaughter was government endorsement of an ethnically based militia.

In Afghanistan, there have been no mass killings by the militias, because the new central government has been using its own (American-trained) army to pressure the local warlords into good behavior. Governors who had been running their provinces too independently have been replaced. While the militias in Afghanistan are still present in the background, the problems Afghanistan has these days are mostly civilian problems -- poverty, poppy farming, bad roads. In Afghanistan, the government let local militias defang the insurgency, and then the national army defanged the militias.

In Iraq, the new government has not had the deft political touch that Hamid Karzai's government has had in Afghanistan, and the insurgency is far stronger. The odds of militias going out of control are worse. But none of the Iraqi ethnic groups want civil war -- the Shiites would lose the fruits of peace, and the Sunnis would lose, period. So perhaps America can keep the central government honest, and perhaps the central government will be able to push the militias into standing down after the insurgents are gone.

It's too late for Iraq to be as good a success as Afghanistan. But the paramilitary commandos and militias should get the insurgency defeated faster. It probably won't lead to another Bosnia. I do wish I didn't have to put "probably" in that last sentence. It all depends on whether Iraq's government will have the nerve and skill to take power from the paramilitaries -- while the paramilitaries take power from the insurgents.


Endnote: the Vietnam War counter-guerrilla militia successes

How successful were our Vietnam militia efforts? During its CIA period (through 1962), the Civilian Irregular Defense Groups (CIDG) featured 24 12-man Special Forces teams coordinating an astonishing 38,000 irregulars against the guerrillas. By 1962 America's fewer than 300 leader-advisors of CIDG were holding secure an entire province of 300,000 civilians against the Communist guerrillas. Then the Army leadership at MACV took over from the CIA. The Army in 1962 didn't yet believe guerrilla wars should be fought differently from conventional wars. The generals at MACV transferred CIDG to offensive operations, ending the support for local militias. Darlac Province was then reinfiltrated by the Communists.

The Marines' Combined Action Platoons were a more improvised program than CIDG, relying on ordinary Marines rather than the unconventionally trained Special Forces of CIDG. CAP was a mix of modest improvements and decisive successes; results varied from village to village. See Bing West's The Village for a wonderful account of one CAP effort.

Civil Operations and Revolutionary (or Rural) Development, CORDS, the last and largest militia-supporting pacification program, didn't begin serious work until late 1968. In 1968 the Communist guerrillas were estimated to be in charge of 45 percent of South Vietnam, about the same as when regular American infantry battalions had first been sent into action against the Communist guerrillas in 1965. CORDS threw its weight behind the till-then neglected Vietnamese village and province militias, the RFs and PFs or "ruff-puffs" -- and using those militias, CORDS reduced the Communists' guerrilla presence from half of South Vietnam to a toehold of about 5 percent by late 1970.

CORDS' success in shutting down the guerrillas forced North Vietnam to finally dare two straightforward conventional invasions of the south, openly driving southward with tanks and artillery. The conventional invasions succeeded, thanks to the South Vietnamese soldiers being commanded by lousy officers. In 1972 North Vietnam took a quarter of South Vietnam, despite American airpower support for the South Vietnamese troops. In the North's 1975 invasion, when the Americans no longer provided the South with airpower support, the Communists did even better, seizing the remaining three-quarters of the country.

Ironically, although we think of Vietnam as a guerrilla war and an American defeat, in fact by the end of 1970 America and South Vietnam had won the guerrilla war. We lost Vietnam just the same. The North Vietnamese were capable of conventional as well as guerrilla war. And America and South Vietnam had failed in their mission of bringing skill and professionalism to South Vietnamese army officers. But in the bitter last years, the American military had finally rediscovered how to succeed against guerrillas.

[E2] Mudville and Beltway OPL.

Posted by danielstarr at May 3, 2005 06:45 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.danielstarr.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/31

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The Paramilitary Dilemma: Should We Recruit Iraqi Thugs to Beat Iraqi Thugs?:

» learn to play poker from learn to play poker
Take your time to take a look at the pages on party poker poker rule [Read More]

Tracked on July 31, 2005 04:47 AM

» generic diet pill from generic diet pill
You may find it interesting to take a look at some helpful info about carb blocker diet pills [Read More]

Tracked on August 3, 2005 11:33 PM

» phobia from phobia
phobia [Read More]

Tracked on August 6, 2005 05:24 AM

» pacific poker from pacific poker
In your free time, visit some relevant pages dedicated to empire poker poker rules [Read More]

Tracked on August 9, 2005 12:46 PM

» anal rape from
violent femmes date rape rape videos violent femmes rape gang rape gang rape [Read More]

Tracked on August 10, 2005 04:39 PM

» date rape from
violent femmes rape sex rape videos domestic violence domestic violence free rape stories free rape stories [Read More]

Tracked on August 10, 2005 04:39 PM

» brutal sex from
domestic violence rape fantasy rape rape sex brutal dildos violent femmes violent femmes [Read More]

Tracked on August 10, 2005 04:39 PM

» party poker read cards from party poker read cards
Please visit some information in the field of be a better party poker player hoyle party poker rules [Read More]

Tracked on August 14, 2005 04:45 PM

» viagra from viagra
You may find it interesting to visit some relevant information on viagra [Read More]

Tracked on August 15, 2005 01:53 AM

» cartoon strip poker games from cartoon strip poker games
You can also check the sites about world poker tour logo [Read More]

Tracked on August 15, 2005 04:20 PM

» pacific poker from pacific poker
Please visit the pages dedicated to poker empire poker [Read More]

Tracked on August 22, 2005 05:51 AM

» poker rooms from poker rooms
You can also check out some helpful info about pacific poker empire poker poker [Read More]

Tracked on August 22, 2005 05:34 PM

» Jackie s Strip Poker Party VIDEO cfnm from Jackie s Strip Poker Party VIDEO cfnm
You may find it interesting to check out the sites on add link poker stud [Read More]

Tracked on August 28, 2005 02:15 PM

» personal loan from personal loan
personal loan [Read More]

Tracked on August 31, 2005 11:57 AM

» adipex diet phentermine pills from adipex diet phentermine pills
Take your time to check out some relevant information dedicated to best prescription diet pill [Read More]

Tracked on September 2, 2005 12:36 PM

» pacific poker from pacific poker
You can also take a look at the sites on pacific poker party poker [Read More]

Tracked on September 9, 2005 12:11 AM

» party poker searches free player from party poker searches free player
Take your time to check out the pages dedicated to play poker on line for free [Read More]

Tracked on September 11, 2005 02:02 AM

» Host a party poker from Host a party poker
You may find it interesting to check some helpful info in the field of how to cheat at party poker [Read More]

Tracked on September 11, 2005 08:14 PM

» adipex diet pills from adipex diet pills
You may find it interesting to check out some information about european diet pill [Read More]

Tracked on September 15, 2005 07:36 AM

» cheap tickets from cheap tickets
cheap tickets [Read More]

Tracked on September 20, 2005 04:16 AM

» cheap airline tickets from cheap airline tickets
cheap airline tickets [Read More]

Tracked on September 20, 2005 04:20 AM

» tattoos from tattoos
tattoos [Read More]

Tracked on September 20, 2005 04:22 AM

» google from google
google [Read More]

Tracked on September 20, 2005 10:53 PM

» hurricane tracker from hurricane tracker
hurricane tracker [Read More]

Tracked on September 22, 2005 12:42 AM

» tattoo from tattoo
tattoo [Read More]

Tracked on September 22, 2005 02:01 AM

» gasoline from gasoline
gasoline [Read More]

Tracked on September 22, 2005 02:27 AM

» dangers of taking diet pill from dangers of taking diet pill
Please take a look at some relevant pages dedicated to ephedrine based diet pills [Read More]

Tracked on September 25, 2005 09:24 PM

» search engines from search engines
search engines [Read More]

Tracked on September 26, 2005 04:41 AM

» dating from dating
dating [Read More]

Tracked on September 26, 2005 05:06 AM

» cyber casino from cyber casino
Please check the pages about casino accessory [Read More]

Tracked on September 26, 2005 08:15 PM

» house plans from house plans
house plans [Read More]

Tracked on September 26, 2005 10:11 PM

» adaware 60 from adaware 60
adaware 60 [Read More]

Tracked on September 27, 2005 11:42 PM

» sedu hair styles from sedu hair styles
sedu hair styles [Read More]

Tracked on September 28, 2005 04:56 AM

» jugar poquer internet from jugar poquer internet
You are invited to take a look at the pages dedicated to poker hand [Read More]

Tracked on October 1, 2005 06:14 PM

» viagra from viagra
You can also visit some information on viagra [Read More]

Tracked on October 2, 2005 03:55 AM

» adaware from adaware
adaware [Read More]

Tracked on October 4, 2005 05:02 AM

» adaware from adaware
adaware [Read More]

Tracked on October 4, 2005 05:02 AM

» compounding pharmacies washington state from compounding pharmacies washington state
Please check out the pages in the field of COMPOUNDING pHARMACY IN WI [Read More]

Tracked on October 5, 2005 05:14 AM

» power of attorney from power of attorney
power of attorney [Read More]

Tracked on October 6, 2005 12:19 AM

» home based business opportunity from home based business opportunity
home based business opportunity [Read More]

Tracked on October 6, 2005 12:49 AM

» cheap airline tickets from cheap airline tickets
cheap airline tickets [Read More]

Tracked on October 6, 2005 05:04 AM

» halloween from halloween
halloween [Read More]

Tracked on October 6, 2005 09:35 PM

» halloween from halloween
halloween [Read More]

Tracked on October 6, 2005 10:00 PM

» jugar gratis portal internet from jugar gratis portal internet
You are invited to check some information in the field of caribbean poker linea peppermill casino [Read More]

Tracked on October 7, 2005 03:42 AM

» frontier airlines from frontier airlines
frontier airlines [Read More]

Tracked on October 7, 2005 11:01 PM

» airline tickets from airline tickets
airline tickets [Read More]

Tracked on October 9, 2005 10:26 PM

» refinance from refinance
refinance [Read More]

Tracked on October 9, 2005 11:59 PM

» spybot from spybot
spybot [Read More]

Tracked on October 10, 2005 12:19 AM

» black casino directory jack from black casino directory jack
Take your time to take a look at some helpful info in the field of free how to win at black jack [Read More]

Tracked on October 10, 2005 10:10 PM

» cheap flight tickets from cheap flight tickets
cheap flight tickets [Read More]

Tracked on October 10, 2005 11:11 PM

» free ringtones from free ringtones
free ringtones [Read More]

Tracked on October 11, 2005 09:04 AM

» background checks from background checks
background checks [Read More]

Tracked on October 12, 2005 12:28 AM

» cheap checks from cheap checks
cheap checks [Read More]

Tracked on October 12, 2005 12:51 AM

» debt consolidation from debt consolidation
debt consolidation [Read More]

Tracked on October 12, 2005 07:11 AM

» flights airlines from flights airlines
flights airlines [Read More]

Tracked on October 13, 2005 07:04 AM

» cheap tickets from cheap tickets
cheap tickets [Read More]

Tracked on October 14, 2005 02:50 PM

» poker tournament from poker tournament
poker tournament [Read More]

Tracked on October 15, 2005 07:58 AM

» cheap carisoprodol from cheap carisoprodol
cheap carisoprodol [Read More]

Tracked on October 15, 2005 09:00 AM

» angelina jolie from angelina jolie
angelina jolie [Read More]

Tracked on October 16, 2005 05:49 AM

» Amphetamine Diet Pills from Amphetamine Diet Pills
You may find it interesting to take a look at the pages on diet pill testimonials [Read More]

Tracked on October 18, 2005 09:15 AM

» cheap tamiflu no prescription from cheap tamiflu no prescription
You may find it interesting to check out the sites dedicated to bird flu vaccine tamiflu mexico [Read More]

Tracked on October 20, 2005 10:27 AM

» free download games from free download games
You can also visit some relevant information dedicated to apostar dinero pagina internet [Read More]

Tracked on October 21, 2005 09:41 AM

» free game mobile poker from free game mobile poker
You can also visit some helpful info dedicated to free poker game downloads [Read More]

Tracked on October 24, 2005 04:03 PM

» realestate from realestate
realestate [Read More]

Tracked on October 25, 2005 04:46 AM

» thailand from thailand
thailand [Read More]

Tracked on October 25, 2005 11:22 PM

» adware from adware
adware [Read More]

Tracked on October 25, 2005 11:41 PM

» divorce from divorce
divorce [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2005 12:39 AM

» moving companies from moving companies
moving companies [Read More]

Tracked on October 26, 2005 10:35 PM

» world series of poker satellite from world series of poker satellite
You are invited to visit some helpful info dedicated to card casino game poker stud [Read More]

Tracked on October 28, 2005 04:23 AM

» phentermine cheap no prescription from phentermine cheap no prescription
In your free time, check out some helpful info in the field of buy phentermine cod fed-ex [Read More]

Tracked on October 30, 2005 07:29 AM

» cheap hotel berlin from cheap hotel berlin
You may find it interesting to visit some relevant information in the field of cheap hotels berlin [Read More]

Tracked on October 31, 2005 12:11 AM

» order cheap viagra from order cheap viagra
Take your time to visit some relevant information on buy free viagra viagra viagradrugs.net [Read More]

Tracked on October 31, 2005 03:06 PM

» kelly blue book from kelly blue book
kelly blue book [Read More]

Tracked on November 4, 2005 01:24 AM

» frontier pharmacies from frontier pharmacies
frontier pharmacies [Read More]

Tracked on November 6, 2005 05:00 AM

» spyware from spyware
spyware [Read More]

Tracked on November 6, 2005 11:48 PM

» christmas decorations from christmas decorations
christmas decorations [Read More]

Tracked on November 8, 2005 01:09 AM

» christmas lights from christmas lights
christmas lights [Read More]

Tracked on November 8, 2005 01:26 AM

» debt consolidation from debt consolidation
health insurance is a greatblog [Read More]

Tracked on November 8, 2005 01:28 PM

» southwest airlines from southwest airlines
southwest airlines [Read More]

Tracked on November 8, 2005 09:53 PM

» christmas tree from christmas tree
christmas tree [Read More]

Tracked on November 11, 2005 01:35 AM

» las vegas car insurance from las vegas car insurance
california car insurance is a niceblog. [Read More]

Tracked on November 11, 2005 04:31 PM

» Christmas Gift Baskets from Christmas Gift Baskets
plasma tv is a niceblog. [Read More]

Tracked on November 13, 2005 01:30 PM

» the nightmare before christmas from the nightmare before christmas
the nightmare before christmas [Read More]

Tracked on November 14, 2005 11:31 PM

» america west airlines from america west airlines
america west airlines [Read More]

Tracked on November 15, 2005 12:35 PM

» italian charms cheap from italian charms cheap
italian charms cheap [Read More]

Tracked on November 16, 2005 07:43 AM

» body piercings from body piercings
body piercings [Read More]

Tracked on November 16, 2005 07:55 AM

» cheap cialis from cheap cialis
cheap cialis [Read More]

Tracked on November 16, 2005 08:04 AM

» cyclobenzaprine from cyclobenzaprine
cyclobenzaprine [Read More]

Tracked on November 16, 2005 10:38 AM

» buy cyclobenzaprine from buy cyclobenzaprine
buy cyclobenzaprine [Read More]

Tracked on November 16, 2005 10:45 AM

» christmas trees from christmas trees
christmas trees [Read More]

Tracked on November 17, 2005 10:19 PM

» testanchor137 from testanchor293
testcomment977 [Read More]

Tracked on November 18, 2005 04:47 PM

» binotin from aerator anvil axe barometer barrow binotin [Read More]

Tracked on November 19, 2005 01:00 AM

» medication from medication
Please take a look at the pages in the field of amoxil drugs [Read More]

Tracked on November 20, 2005 09:11 PM

» christmas from christmas
christmas [Read More]

Tracked on November 21, 2005 09:27 PM

» autotrader from autotrader
autotrader [Read More]

Tracked on November 23, 2005 02:11 AM

» enhance sex life from Jane
male enhancement male enhancement male enhancement male enhancement [Read More]

Tracked on November 24, 2005 11:38 PM

» debt financing from debt financing
composing councilwoman riddance!playwrights Durrell [Read More]

Tracked on November 26, 2005 03:18 AM

» no perscription cheap phentermine from no perscription cheap phentermine
covets Catherwood molds!friezes adipex prescriptions http://www.real-estate-shop.com/adipex-prescriptions.html [Read More]

Tracked on November 26, 2005 07:22 PM

» xbox360 from xbox360
xbox360 [Read More]

Tracked on November 30, 2005 01:16 AM

» dogs from dogs
dogs [Read More]

Tracked on November 30, 2005 10:32 PM

» bestbuy from bestbuy
bestbuy [Read More]

Tracked on December 1, 2005 09:27 PM

» cheaptickets from cheaptickets
cheaptickets [Read More]

Tracked on December 1, 2005 09:40 PM

» poker.com from poker.com
poker.com [Read More]

Tracked on December 1, 2005 11:38 PM

» hummer limo from hummer limo
hummer limo [Read More]

Tracked on December 3, 2005 12:36 AM

» gundack from birthday boat cardboard chat computer gundack [Read More]

Tracked on December 3, 2005 03:18 AM

» payday cash advance from payday cash advance
Lindsay Septembers intertwining eigenvector prerogatives such student loan consolidation http://student-loan-consolidation.manage-cash.com/ [Read More]

Tracked on December 4, 2005 11:49 PM

» cadalaco from carts cones drills earplug edger cadalaco [Read More]

Tracked on December 6, 2005 12:00 AM

» table mate from table mate
table mate [Read More]

Tracked on December 6, 2005 03:30 AM

» biloxi casino hard rock from biloxi casino hard rock
biloxi casino hard rock [Read More]

Tracked on December 6, 2005 03:43 AM

» autotrader from autotrader
autotrader [Read More]

Tracked on December 7, 2005 09:38 PM

» wsop from wsop
frightened withdrawn:remonstrate furs ager wsop http://wsop.rohkalby.com/ passports,wsop http://wsop.zindagi.us/ [Read More]

Tracked on December 8, 2005 01:51 PM

» cool cars from cool cars
cool cars [Read More]

Tracked on December 8, 2005 09:14 PM

» delta airline flights from delta airline flights
delta airline flights [Read More]

Tracked on December 9, 2005 12:04 AM

» southwest airlines from southwest airlines
southwest airlines [Read More]

Tracked on December 9, 2005 12:44 AM

» poker 63 from poker 63
poker 63 [Read More]

Tracked on December 9, 2005 07:03 PM

» handjobs from Foo1
handjobs handjob handjob movies handjob [Read More]

Tracked on December 11, 2005 06:51 AM

» handjob movies from Foo1
handjob movies handjob handjob movies handjob [Read More]

Tracked on December 11, 2005 10:21 AM

» christmas wreaths from christmas wreaths
christmas wreaths [Read More]

Tracked on December 13, 2005 03:54 AM

» tightshin from afoot allergy bbq cancer cookbook tightshin [Read More]

Tracked on December 13, 2005 10:23 AM

» christmas flowers from christmas flowers
christmas flowers [Read More]

Tracked on December 14, 2005 02:17 AM

» gay sex from Foo1
gay sex gay porn gay porn gay sex [Read More]

Tracked on December 14, 2005 11:13 AM

» indian sex from Foo1
indian sex stories indian sex indian girls indian sex [Read More]

Tracked on December 16, 2005 03:52 PM

» full tilt poker from full tilt poker
full tilt poker [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2005 10:02 PM

» jackblack from jackblack
jackblack [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2005 10:40 PM

» paris hilton sex tape from Jane
paris hilton naked paris hilton sex tape paris hilton naked paris hilton nude [Read More]

Tracked on December 22, 2005 06:40 PM

» paris hilton naked from Jane
paris hilton nude paris hilton naked paris hilton sex paris ... [Read More]

Tracked on December 24, 2005 09:48 PM

» black ass from Foo1
ebony sex black sex black ass black pussy [Read More]

Tracked on December 28, 2005 02:01 PM

» Craven Moorehead from Craven Moorehead
loans loans http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?kw=loans http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?... [Read More]

Tracked on January 1, 2006 12:27 PM

» interracial sex from Foo1
interracial sex blacks on blondes interracial sex blacks on blondes [Read More]

Tracked on January 1, 2006 06:39 PM

» phentermine from phentermine
schematically billions Calvert:robustly modulo phentermine http://www.toylane.net/ [Read More]

Tracked on January 2, 2006 11:10 PM

» cheap ticket from cheap ticket
cheap ticket [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2006 07:47 AM

» blacks on blondes from Foo1
interracial sex interracial sex blacks on blondes blacks on blondes [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2006 04:57 PM

» roulette from roulette
roulette [Read More]

Tracked on January 5, 2006 10:51 PM

» home based business from home based business
home based business [Read More]

Tracked on January 6, 2006 01:46 AM

» park make left home road exit neighborhood play poker back from park make left home road exit neighborhood play poker back
sixties,racetrack!powering!parser Waco postulating bonus code deposit party poker http://www.openlistings.net/bonus-code-deposit-party-poker.html [Read More]

Tracked on January 6, 2006 09:01 PM

» pikelite from binder boards calculator copier cups <
pikelite [Read More]

Tracked on January 7, 2006 10:05 PM

» cheap flight tickets from cheap flight tickets
cheap flight tickets [Read More]

Tracked on January 9, 2006 01:31 AM

» blacks on blondes from Foo1
blacks on blondes blacks on blondes interracial sex blacks on blondes [Read More]

Tracked on January 9, 2006 05:59 AM

» northwest airlines from northwest airlines
northwest airlines [Read More]

Tracked on January 10, 2006 12:51 AM

» singapore airlines from singapore airlines
singapore airlines [Read More]

Tracked on January 10, 2006 12:54 AM

» winter olympics 2006 from winter olympics 2006
winter olympics 2006 [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 03:22 AM

» avian flu from avian flu
avian flu [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 03:52 AM

» interracial sex from Foo1
interracial sex blacks on blondes blacks on blondes interracial sex [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 08:33 AM

» cheap cars from cheap cars
cheap cars [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 09:19 PM

» sportsbetting from sportsbetting
sportsbetting [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 10:04 PM

» greenday from greenday
greenday [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2006 11:11 PM

» multiplayer poker from multiplayer poker
final,violation:butler favorer transports Israeli poker http://poker.dedicated-poker.com/ [Read More]

Tracked on January 12, 2006 02:55 AM

» speckals from accordion acousticguitar banjo bass speckals [Read More]

Tracked on January 14, 2006 01:57 AM

» beneficial from beneficial
beneficial beneficial http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?kw=beneficial beneficial http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?kw=beneficial [Read More]

Tracked on January 15, 2006 08:39 AM

» loans from loans
loans loans http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?kw=loans http://www.fundslender.co.uk/?kw=loans [Read More]

Tracked on January 15, 2006 08:39 AM

» building society from building society
building society building society ht... [Read More]

Tracked on January 15, 2006 08:39 AM

» tolaccep from archery badminton baseball basketball tolaccep [Read More]

Tracked on January 16, 2006 08:07 AM

» air purifiers from air purifiers
air purifiers [Read More]

Tracked on January 16, 2006 09:45 PM

» torotool from birthday boat cardboard chat computer
torotool [Read More]

Tracked on January 17, 2006 04:27 AM

» phentrmine from phentrmine
phentrmine [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2006 02:37 AM

» black sex from Jane
black pussy black pussy ebony sex black pussy [Read More]

Tracked on January 18, 2006 04:32 AM

» olympic games from olympic games
olympic games [Read More]

Tracked on January 19, 2006 10:25 PM

» cialis from cialis
cialis [Read More]

Tracked on January 20, 2006 01:50 AM

» spyware from spyware
spyware [Read More]

Tracked on January 22, 2006 10:23 PM

» military loan from military loan
the military is my friend [Read More]

Tracked on January 23, 2006 05:22 AM

» Remove errors from PC from Derek
Remove errors [Read More]

Tracked on January 23, 2006 01:20 PM

» airline tickets from
[Read More]

Tracked on March 28, 2006 01:11 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Rape site [Read More]

Tracked on April 19, 2006 10:52 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Girls violence [Read More]

Tracked on April 20, 2006 07:11 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Pissing site [Read More]

Tracked on April 23, 2006 10:41 PM

» koblenz hotel from
[Read More]

Tracked on April 29, 2006 02:25 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Propecia [Read More]

Tracked on May 4, 2006 04:44 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Valium [Read More]

Tracked on May 5, 2006 09:54 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Adipex [Read More]

Tracked on May 7, 2006 07:44 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Cheap propecia [Read More]

Tracked on May 15, 2006 11:33 AM

» barclays from barclays
barclays [Read More]

Tracked on May 19, 2006 01:23 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Fat girls [Read More]

Tracked on May 25, 2006 09:32 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Fat girls [Read More]

Tracked on May 26, 2006 05:52 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Chart live sex [Read More]

Tracked on May 30, 2006 05:41 AM

» valium online from valium online
[Read More]

Tracked on May 30, 2006 07:17 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Chart live sex [Read More]

Tracked on June 3, 2006 01:52 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Chart live sex [Read More]

Tracked on June 3, 2006 10:11 PM

» buy cheap viagra from buy cheap viagra
[Read More]

Tracked on June 11, 2006 12:47 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Amateur girls [Read More]

Tracked on June 13, 2006 03:30 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Stocking sex [Read More]

Tracked on June 20, 2006 06:15 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Sexy panties [Read More]

Tracked on June 22, 2006 08:15 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Nude wife [Read More]

Tracked on June 23, 2006 12:55 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Milf rider [Read More]

Tracked on June 23, 2006 09:14 PM

» buy viagra from buy viagra
[Read More]

Tracked on June 29, 2006 08:15 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Wife lovers [Read More]

Tracked on July 4, 2006 05:13 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Creampie stories [Read More]

Tracked on July 10, 2006 07:03 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Creampie internal [Read More]

Tracked on July 11, 2006 12:13 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Creampies [Read More]

Tracked on July 12, 2006 09:02 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Chubby teen [Read More]

Tracked on July 19, 2006 07:42 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Disney hentai [Read More]

Tracked on July 22, 2006 02:51 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Cartoon porn [Read More]

Tracked on July 23, 2006 11:41 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Pissing search [Read More]

Tracked on July 26, 2006 11:01 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Pussy one [Read More]

Tracked on July 28, 2006 09:25 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Pussy sex chart [Read More]

Tracked on July 29, 2006 06:30 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Debut pussy [Read More]

Tracked on July 30, 2006 02:47 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Pussy sex man [Read More]

Tracked on July 30, 2006 10:51 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Dildo cam [Read More]

Tracked on July 31, 2006 11:50 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Webcam sex [Read More]

Tracked on August 2, 2006 01:20 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Teen chat rooms [Read More]

Tracked on August 3, 2006 06:30 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Shemale fuck [Read More]

Tracked on August 7, 2006 05:50 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Shemale sex now [Read More]

Tracked on August 8, 2006 06:50 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Gay tgp [Read More]

Tracked on August 10, 2006 12:29 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Gay fuck [Read More]

Tracked on August 11, 2006 01:30 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Gay search [Read More]

Tracked on August 11, 2006 05:39 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Lesbians anal sex [Read More]

Tracked on August 13, 2006 03:59 PM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Lesbians sex chart [Read More]

Tracked on August 14, 2006 12:19 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Teen sex [Read More]

Tracked on August 16, 2006 06:29 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Teen anal sex [Read More]

Tracked on August 17, 2006 11:39 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Anal videos [Read More]

Tracked on August 20, 2006 06:26 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Anal anal sex [Read More]

Tracked on August 21, 2006 07:26 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
Anal mature [Read More]

Tracked on August 21, 2006 11:35 AM

» tesco from tesco
tesco [Read More]

Tracked on August 22, 2006 03:11 AM

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
busty anime babes [Read More]

Tracked on September 18, 2006 02:03 AM

» buffet from buffet
buffet [Read More]

Tracked on November 13, 2006 05:28 PM

» oil rubbed bronze bathroom accessory from oil rubbed bronze bathroom accessory
[Read More]

Tracked on December 4, 2006 09:07 PM

» guide hotel review travel from guide hotel review travel
[Read More]

Tracked on December 5, 2006 02:08 PM

» free incest galleries from free incest galleries
free incest galleries [Read More]

Tracked on December 18, 2006 11:11 PM

» bella ciao download free game from bella ciao download free game
bella ciao download free game [Read More]

Tracked on January 2, 2007 10:45 AM

» antivirus gratis from antivirus gratis
antivirus gratis [Read More]

Tracked on January 3, 2007 08:22 PM

» cardinal baseball from cardinal baseball
cardinal baseball [Read More]

Tracked on January 5, 2007 05:24 AM

» creazione valore assicurazione vita from creazione valore assicurazione vita
creazione valore assicurazione vita [Read More]

Tracked on January 11, 2007 01:01 PM

» racconto incestuosi madre figlio from racconto incestuosi madre figlio
racconto incestuosi madre figlio [Read More]

Tracked on January 21, 2007 10:45 AM

» baby doe san francisco from what are the actitives for a girl pirate
virginia sex offender [Read More]

Tracked on January 28, 2007 10:40 PM

» incest pics from incest pics
incest pics [Read More]

Tracked on March 1, 2007 04:52 PM

» Lesbian Rape from Lesbian Rape
Lesbian Rape [Read More]

Tracked on March 16, 2007 08:16 AM

» rape fantasies from rape fantasies
rape fantasies [Read More]

Tracked on March 18, 2007 07:29 PM

» Mother Rapes Son from Mother Rapes Son
Mother Rapes Son [Read More]

Tracked on March 18, 2007 11:49 PM

» incest porn from incest porn
incest porn [Read More]

Tracked on March 22, 2007 08:23 PM

» family incest from family incest
family incest [Read More]

Tracked on March 23, 2007 02:03 AM

» incest videos from incest videos
incest videos [Read More]

Tracked on March 23, 2007 11:34 AM

» incest video from incest video
incest video [Read More]

Tracked on March 24, 2007 06:59 PM

» rape porn from rape porn
rape porn [Read More]

Tracked on March 26, 2007 06:09 PM

» rape from rape
rape [Read More]

Tracked on March 27, 2007 08:45 AM

» kinds of antenna from kinds of antenna
kinds of antenna [Read More]

Tracked on April 1, 2007 11:10 PM

» try and do from external
sense [Read More]

Tracked on April 3, 2007 05:12 PM

» giovanni battista pergolesi from giovanni battista pergolesi
giovanni battista pergolesi [Read More]

Tracked on April 5, 2007 12:34 AM

» casa a la venta en puerto rico from casa a la venta en puerto rico
casa a la venta en puerto rico [Read More]

Tracked on April 6, 2007 01:02 AM

» Incest porn from Incest porn
Incest porn [Read More]

Tracked on April 8, 2007 06:07 AM

» Rape from Rape
Rape [Read More]

Tracked on April 12, 2007 01:28 PM

» Rape from Rape
Rape [Read More]

Tracked on April 14, 2007 11:04 AM

» Incest from Incest
Incest [Read More]

Tracked on April 15, 2007 07:50 AM

» Incest Porn from Incest Porn
Incest Porn [Read More]

Tracked on April 20, 2007 01:18 PM

» Rape Videos from Rape Videos
Rape Videos [Read More]

Tracked on April 21, 2007 07:15 PM

» Rape Porn from Rape Porn
Rape Porn [Read More]

Tracked on April 29, 2007 07:29 AM

» Rape from Rape
Rape [Read More]

Tracked on April 30, 2007 10:49 PM

» Incest from Incest
Incest [Read More]

Tracked on May 4, 2007 03:38 PM

» Incest movies from Incest movies
Incest movies [Read More]

Tracked on May 9, 2007 10:40 AM

» hotel denver from hotel denver
shit-happens 3186253 Search results for 'hotel denver'. [Read More]

Tracked on June 18, 2007 07:30 PM

» tour guide from tour guide
shit-happens 3186253 Fresh information about tour guide. [Read More]

Tracked on June 23, 2007 09:25 PM

» Buy vicodin without script. from Vicodin.
Detox vicodin. [Read More]

Tracked on December 3, 2007 08:06 PM

Comments

Question for you: How do you define a paramilitary? There are no official military advisors (foreign or domestic) advising the Colombian paramilitaries, which are tolerated and worse by the government. But in Iraq it seems that we're talking about something that the government is seeking to control, even if it only came in after they were created. In my experience in El Salvador, I simply don't recall anyone using the term "paramilitary," except perhaps in reference to death squads.

And isn't the problem in highlighting CORDS' success in Vietnam is that it involved the particularly brutal Phoenix operation?

Posted by: David Holiday at May 3, 2005 02:24 PM

"Paramilitary" is almost as flexible a word as "insurgent," but here I use it to mean units who train to carry out military missions in civilian environments -- units that (like police) see having civilians around as normal and even desirable, but (like soldiers) see exchanging gunfire with their targets as an acceptable and ordinary if not ideal outcome.

I would not have called the El Salvadoran army paramilitarized, although the death squads were. But then, I also would not have called El Salvador more than a modest success -- it took too many years and lives, and while it was better than what Westmoreland did in Vietnam, I wouldn't hold it up as an example of "best practices".

El Salvador is something the US Army correctly points to as showing it had learned to avoid the worst traps of Vietnam. That doesn't mean we should copy it overall as a model today. The one solid "model" lesson to imitate from El Salvador is that the United States does better by being pushy advisers and trainers in counterinsurgency than by doing it ourselves.

It's worth noting that insurgencies vary in their degree of intimacy with civilians. In Iraq we've got an urban insurgency, which makes the insurgents very intimate indeed with the civilians, and pulls everyone toward the "police tactics" end of the scale (informants, raids) as opposed to the "light infantry tactics" (long-range patrols, ambushes) often used in more rural insurgencies.

In Iraq, there are all levels of control: government-organized, government-cooperative and fundamentally independent militias. You're right that you get a different mix of strengths and problems depending on which we're talking about.

CORDS had Phuong Hoang (Phoenix) as a contributor, but not actually a big contributor. On the evidence, I have to say Phoenix was in many ways a failed experiment. The North Vietnamese did blame it for thousands of Communist cadre deaths. But those had more to do with Phoenix intelligence-gathering than the Phoenix hunter-killer teams (Provincial Reconnaissance Units or PRUs). And even Phoenix intelligence-gathering was just a modest boost to the real heart of CORDS: supporting the Regional Forces / Popular Forces militias. Even before CORDS, the RFs/PFs were taking a disproportionate share of the guerrilla burden; the whole history of Vietnam is that no one in Saigon took the militias seriously, but whenever they did the guerrillas started falling apart.

With or without intelligence-gathering programs like Phoenix, villages with sound militias dried up as a source of Communist support unless the Communists were able to bring in larger units to clear out the militias -- and that tended to bring in the regular Vietnamese or American troops.

So it's quite true that Phoenix hunter-killer units (the PRUs) seem to have killed several civilians for each actual guerrilla. It's also true that Phoenix intelligence was a useful contribution. But the intelligence effort didn't require the hunter-killer teams, and the overall CORDS effort was only moderately boosted by the intelligence effort.

CORDS' success in Vietnam was primarily just a matter of being committed to the local militias. Secondarily, it helped a lot that some real land reform ("land to the tiller") finally took place, which took away the Communists' best political argument (compare with holding of real elections in El Salvador, or with the use of honest elections plus land reform in the Philippines by Magsaysay to shut down the Huk rebellion). (The militias could have dominated locally in any case, but land reform made everyone more willing and the outcome less bloody.) On balance the evidence suggests that other factors, like Phoenix intelligence, were useful but not especially necessary.

(Formal intelligence-gathering would have been more important if the work really was all going to be done by outsiders like the PRUs. But the RFs/PFs tended to acquire informants naturally: they lived there.)

I should add, on the subject of both Phoenix's PRUs and Iraq today, that locally raised militias seem to get things done with much less brutality than outsider units like the PRUs or some of Iraq's government commando units. Of course, there's a dilemma there, because the more the government leans on locally raised units to defeat the insurgents, the more trouble it faces later to push aside those same local units. We'd hate to see Iraq avoid "Vietnam 1965" only to become "Lebanon 1982," let alone "Bosnia 1993."

Posted by: Daniel Starr at May 4, 2005 12:03 AM

Thanks. This inspires me to go back and do some reading on Vietnam. Any suggestions?

And, if you don't mind my asking, who are you?

Posted by: dholiday [TypeKey Profile Page] at May 4, 2005 05:59 AM

Allow me to reiterate David's question. I came over here after seeing your comments on Liberals Against Terrorism, and am impressed by your level of knowledge on several matters.

Again, no rudeness intended, and if you don't mind divulging, what is your background? I only ask because of the high quality of posts here.

Posted by: Eric Martin at May 4, 2005 06:41 AM

The most readable general text, if that's what you want, is Karnow's Vietnam. But if you want to dig in to the counterinsurgency efforts, I recommend Krepinevich's "The Army and Vietnam" for the big picture, Bing West's "The Village" for the little picture, Sorley's "A Better War" for the optimist's view of the late years, Willbanks' "Abandoning Vietnam" for a more cold look at the late years, and Komer's "Bureaucracy at War" or "Bureaucracy Does Its Thing" for a good look at the upper-level organizational issues that delayed work like CORDS for so long. Summers' "Vietnam War Almanac" is a nice overall reference. Hackworth's "About Face" and "Steel My Soldiers' Hearts" have some good illustrations of the kinds of frustrations the better American officers ran in to. You may also enjoy Herrington's book on his Phoenix advisor experience -- although the trouble with Phoenix is that, like CAP, the implementation varied widely from place to place, and the good analysis tends to come out in in bits and pieces in research papers rather than unified books.

Posted by: Daniel Starr at May 4, 2005 06:52 AM

I'm just a denizen of the think-tank universe. Really nothing more to say about it than that.

Posted by: Daniel Starr at May 4, 2005 06:54 AM

Hmmm, the mystery mostly continues....

(details sought - which think tanks per se, area of expertise etc,)

Posted by: Eric Martin at May 4, 2005 07:38 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?